ON LEAVE, BUT NOT OFF THE HOOK: WHEN OFF-DUTY SOCIAL MEDIA LANDS YOU IN HOT WATER

Our work selves and our private selves are rarely one and the same. These two personas operate in different environments, carry different expectations and give rise to different patterns of behaviour. Outside of working hours, employees are entitled to enjoy their personal lives, share their experiences and express themselves, and social media has become a primary forum for doing so.

There is, however, a fine line between private and professional conduct. Content shared on social media is rarely confined to its intended audience and may readily come to the attention of colleagues, clients and employers. As such, before publishing any post, an employee should consider one simple question: would I be comfortable explaining this post to my employer, or at the CCMA?

Employers have a legitimate interest in protecting their reputation and public image, and they rely on their employees to uphold that reputation, both within and beyond the workplace. This does not mean that every social media post will result in disciplinary action. An employer's disciplinary authority over conduct committed outside the workplace and outside working hours exists only where there is a sufficient causal nexus between the employee's conduct and the employer's business, such that the conduct may properly be characterised as misconduct.

Examples of conduct which may establish such a nexus include the publication of racist or discriminatory remarks in a group or forum accessible to co-workers and clients of the employer, or the posting of images depicting the use of illegal substances while the employee is wearing company-branded clothing.

The fact that the conduct occurred after hours does not, in itself, afford the employee blanket protection. The Labour Court has confirmed that an employer may discipline an employee for misconduct committed away from the workplace, although this is an exception to the general rule that an employer has no competence to discipline an employee for conduct that is not work-related and that occurs after hours and away from the workplace. In determining whether the exception applies, the Labour Court has drawn on the test laid down by the Labour Appeal Court in Hoechst (Pty) Ltd v Chemical Workers Industrial Union and Another (1993) 14 ILJ 1449 (LAC) (hereinafter referred to as “Hoechst”). Although Hoechst concerned the competence to discipline for misconduct not covered by an employer’s disciplinary code, the same enquiry has been applied to off-duty conduct. The question is whether the misconduct had the effect of destroying or seriously damaging the employment relationship. This depends on a multi-faceted factual enquiry, which includes the nature of the misconduct, the nature of the employee’s work, the employer’s size, profile and position in the market place, and the impact of the misconduct on the workforce and on the relationship between the employer and the employee. The question is thus whether conduct complained of has the effect of destroying or seriously damaging the employment relationship. The employer bears the onus of demonstrating the requisite connection between that conduct and its business.

These principles were applied by the Labour Court in Edcon Limited v Cantamessa and Others (JR30/17) [2019] ZALCJHB 273; (2020) 41 ILJ 195 (LC); [2020] 2 BLLR 186 (LC) (11 October 2019). In this case, a senior buyer employed by Edcon published a post on her Facebook account in December 2015, while on annual leave, in which she referred to the country’s leaders as “stupid monkeys”. The Court found this to be a racial slur directed at Black members of government. Her Facebook profile identified her as a Fashion Buyer at Edcon. A customer complained to Edcon about the post, which then attracted negative attention on social media and in the press, with some users threatening to stop supporting Edcon. Following a disciplinary enquiry, the employee was dismissed.

The CCMA found the dismissal to be substantively unfair, reasoning, inter alia, that the post had been published while the employee was not at work, that it did not relate to her employment, that Edcon’s policies did not regulate off-duty conduct, and that Edcon had not proved any financial loss. The employee was awarded compensation equivalent to 12 (twelve) months' remuneration. On review, the Labour Court set the award aside and held that the dismissal was substantively fair. The Court found that, because the employee's Facebook profile publicly identified Edcon as her employer, and because her role as a buyer contributed to shaping Edcon’s brand, the necessary connection between her conduct and Edcon's business had been established. In those circumstances, she was under a duty to refrain from conduct which could draw Edcon into controversy, particularly given that Edcon's business depended heavily on its public image, advertising and marketing. The Court further found that the post constituted advocacy of hatred based on race and amounted to incitement to cause harm. It therefore fell outside the protection of the right to freedom of expression. The Court noted that the employee remained free to criticise the government; it was the racist content of the post that placed it beyond Constitutional protection. The employee's conduct exposed Edcon to a real risk of reputational harm. Importantly, the Court held that Edcon was not required to prove actual financial loss; a real risk of reputational harm was sufficient. Notwithstanding the employee’s long service and clean disciplinary record, dismissal was found to be an appropriate sanction.

Social media platforms are pervasive and highly interconnected, and content shared in a seemingly private capacity may quickly reach colleagues, clients and other persons associated with the workplace. Employees should therefore exercise caution and sound judgement before publishing content online.

This is particularly relevant as the festive season approaches. Year-end functions, holidays and time away from the office often bring a more relaxed attitude to what is shared online. Notably, the post in Edcon was published on 20 December, while the employee was on annual leave. Being on leave or off duty does not switch off the employment relationship. Before posting, commenting on or sharing content this holiday season, employees should bear in mind that identifying their employer on their profile increases the likelihood that their posts will be associated with that employer, that “private” groups and chats offer little protection once a screenshot is taken, and that a single careless post may have consequences that last well beyond the holidays, including disciplinary action and, in serious cases, dismissal.

For employers, a clear social media policy which expressly extends to off-duty conduct is advisable. In Edcon, the commissioner placed weight on the fact that the employer’s policies did not regulate off-duty conduct.

Written by Phillipa Currie

We trust that you found this article informative, please email info@hjwattorneys.co.za for assistance with all your legal queries.

This article is provided for informational purposes only and should not be substituted for legal advice on any specific matter. Any opinions expressed herein are subject to the law as at the time of writing and will change in accordance with any change in the law. We recommend that you contact HJW Attorneys & Conveyancers at info@hjwattorneys.co.za directly for advice applicable to your specific matter.

Next
Next

CONSTITUTIONAL SHIFT IN SOUTH AFRICAN FAMILY LAW: THE END OF THE LEX DOMICILII MATRIMONII RULE